What do you think of 13-year-old girl who died of drunkenness and nine friends at the same table were accused of going to court?
Brother Liu
The Cangxi County People's Court of Guangyuan City publicly heard this controversial case. The plaintiff is Liu Dage, a middle-aged widow, and the defendant is nine young men and women in their prime. Several young people, the oldest being 22 years old, sat in the dock dejected and depressed, while 52-year-old Liu Dage became old overnight 10 years old.
On the day of the crime, Qin Xiao had been entangled with nine defendants, drinking wine, but had an accident and died in a hotel in the county. Qin Xiao's father, Liu Dage, believed that the nine defendants should bear the main responsibility for Qin Xiao's death and demanded compensation of more than 300,000 yuan, but the nine defendants had completely different views. The defendants said that they were deeply sympathetic to what happened to Qin Xiao, but it had nothing to do with them. Claiming 300,000 is complete nonsense.
defendant
Qin Xiao is 13 years old and his family is not very good. Her mother remarried, and she lived alone with her father. After graduating from primary school, she went to vocational school instead of junior high school. After studying for a year, she dropped out of school, and then Qin Xiao left home to work in the county. By chance, she met Hou Qian, a girl three years older than her. For a 13-year-old girl, everything is novel, and colorful night shows have great attraction to this girl who came out of a small mountain village.
On the night of the murder, after work, Qin Xiao and her friend Hou Qian went to karaoke bars at the invitation of their friends, during which they each drank a bottle of beer. After leaving the karaoke bar, Hou Qian and Qin Xiao went to another bar to find friends to handle affairs. At this moment, Hou Qian suddenly met some of her old friends. At 1:44 in the morning, four young people, Qin Xiao and Hou Qianhe, went into the grilled fish shop to have some snacks. The smell of grilled fish is overflowing, and someone suggested ordering a bottle of wine to add to the fun.
Qin Xiao is eating at the grilled fish shop.
It is said that wine meets bosom friends, and several young people are similar in age, congenial in personality and just right in atmosphere. Let's push a glass for a change and have a good time. After drinking a few glasses of wine, excitement welled up in her head, and Sogeum's mood reached a commanding height. On a whim, she went outside the grilled fish shop with a man named Huang Liang next to her and began to drink with the guests at other tables, whether she knew it or not. Huang Liang said either good or bad, and finally persuaded Sogeum back to his seat. At 2: 20 in the morning, Qin Xiao got up in the toilet. She wobbled, obviously unable to stand.
At 2: 30 in the morning, the dinner at the grilled fish shop finally came to an end. At this time, the four boys walked first and went home. Hou Qian asked two friends for help and sent Qin Xiao, who had completely finished the movie, to a hotel in the county. On the night of the murder, the surveillance video of the hotel showed that Hou Qian and two young men pushed open the hotel door and dragged Qin Xiao to room 3 1 1. At this time, Qin Xiao has completely lost consciousness.
Qin Xiao was dragged to the hotel.
At 4: 23 in the morning, the three left the hotel, went to the Internet cafe to play games, and left Qin Xiao alone in the room. About half an hour later, Hou Qian and the young man carrying a satchel returned to the hotel room 3 1 1. At 5am, Hou Qian and her friends anxiously dialed 120 to give Qin Xiao first aid. But Qin Xiao missed the best rescue time and lost his precious young life. Brother Liu was furious when he learned the cause and effect of his daughter's death. He complained about two people who were drinking in a bar with Qin Xiao that night, five people who were drinking in a grilled fish shop, and two people who sent Qin Xiao back to the hotel.
The plaintiff's lawyer thinks that when the defendant was drinking with Qin Xiao, he didn't consider that the other party was a minor. They organized a wine bureau, and all the beer and liquor went into battle, which made Qin Xiao drunk as drunk as a fiddler. After being drunk, Qin Xiao didn't take care of himself, which led to Qin Xiao's failure to get timely treatment, and eventually he died because of ineffective rescue. However, the defendant's agent put forward such a statement. First, from the bar to the grilled fish shop, Qin Xiao took the initiative to find wine to drink all night, and no one advised him to drink, let alone drink. Second, Qin Xiao's clothes, words and deeds simply don't show that Qin Xiao is underage, even less than 14 years old.
Qin Xiao
Defendant Hou Qian said that Qin Xiao was drunk and vomited in a big mess. She resisted the pungent smell of wine, sent Qin Xiao back to her room, helped her to wipe her body, feed hot water, change clothes, cover herself with a quilt, and took good care of Qin Xiao. However, the plaintiff's lawyer believes that dizziness, vomiting and unconsciousness all indicate that Qin Xiao's body is in an extremely dangerous state, and he is sending a distress signal to his companions. Regrettably, several defendants did not pay enough attention to it.
During the trial, several defendants said that they had done their best to take care of Qin Xiao who was in a drunken state, but the court held that this was far from enough. Even if Qin Xiao offered to drink on the day of the crime, several defendants were still at fault and still had unshirkable responsibilities. In this case, several defendants failed to fulfill their obligation to send Qin Xiao to the hospital in time, resulting in his unfortunate death due to alcoholism. Nine defendants were subjectively negligent, which had an indirect causal relationship with Qin Xiao's final death, which met the statutory requirements of infringement. They should deal with the consequences of Qin Xiao's death and bear the corresponding civil liability.
judge
After mediation by the court, the nine defendants compensated the plaintiff Liu Dage 1.2 million yuan. Young life has come to an end, but it has triggered a very controversial discussion. Bian Xiao once again warned everyone that we must be kind to life, treat drinking with a correct attitude, and treat friends who drink with you with a responsible attitude. Don't let the tragedy repeat itself.