Is Bayern a cancer of the Bundesliga or has it promoted the development of the Bundesliga? Will the Bundesliga without Bayern be better or worse than it is now?
With the news that Borussia Dortmund and Bayern announced the transfer of Hummels on May 16, captain Dortmund's transfer drama also ushered in the final outcome. Hummels from Bayern Youth Training Camp will return to the home team and form the German national team with boateng and Neuer. According to German media reports, Bayern paid a transfer fee of about 35 million euros for Hummels. Together with Gotze and lewandowski, Bayern signed three core players from its main rival Dortmund in the past three years. Some people think that this is "hurting" the Bundesliga, but others disagree with this view.
From the Three Masters of Pharmaceutical Factory to the Three Masters of Dortmund
In the same year, ze Roberto and Barak switched from pharmaceutical factories to Bayern.
In the past 14 season, Bayern signed 14 players who participated in the Champions League from other teams in the Bundesliga. Now Dortmund's situation is similar to that of Leverkusen at the beginning of this century: it is also very competitive, also won the runner-up in the Champions League, and also lingered in the relegation zone shortly after reaching the Champions League final. Leverkusen won the "King of Sanya" in 200 1-2002 season. That summer, Bayern won two generals, ze Roberto and Barak, from the pharmaceutical factory. In the summer of 2004, Brazilian defender Lucio also moved to Bayern, and the three old teammates reunited. These three players also played a very important role after joining Bayern. Now Dortmund's three teammates are reunited in Bayern, which also reminds people of the "three outstanding pharmaceutical companies" of that year.
Klose moved from Bremen to Bayern Munich.
In addition to Leverkusen and Dortmund, there are three players from Bremen who have participated in the Champions League for five consecutive years and also moved to Bayern. The most famous is undoubtedly Klose. K God apologized to the club management and fans for contacting Bayern Club privately. In addition, German internationals Neuer and Gomez, as well as foreign central defenders Van Bite and Dante who played well in the Bundesliga, also joined Bayern from the Bundesliga team that entered the Champions League last season. Although these clubs have introduced corresponding substitutes (such as mkhitaryan and Obameian) after selling players to Bayern to get the transfer fee, many people think that Bayern has weakened the strength of their main rivals.
Bayern "hurt" the Bundesliga?
Dortmund last picked up the Bundesliga salad plate five years ago.
There are many voices against Bayern's practice of bringing in players from its main competitors. Someone commented on the website of the World Football Forum: "The Bundesliga used to be a fiercely competitive league, but now it is increasingly developing in the direction of Bayern's hegemony. As far as the intensity of the championship is concerned, the Bundesliga was once comparable to the Premier League, but now it is rapidly becoming a league where Bayern monopolizes the championship. " This statement is somewhat exaggerated at first glance. After all, the Premier League is famous for its fierce competition. But judging from the number of champions in the two major leagues since the 20th century, the Premier League has five champions (Manchester United, Arsenal, Chelsea, Manchester City and Leicester) and the Bundesliga has five champions (Bayern, Dortmund, Bremen, Stuttgart and Wolfsburg). Among them, Manchester United won seven championships with 16, and Bayern won 16 with 10.
Of these four people, only Royce stayed in Dortmund.
Judging from the performance of the superior teams, Bayern certainly has more advantages in the Bundesliga than Manchester United in the Premier League. However, there are five different champions, which also shows that the Bundesliga is by no means a backwater. Manchester City won the championship at the last minute in the Premier League, and Patrick Anderson won the championship at the last minute with a free kick. The championship drama lasted at least five times in the last round. However, it is difficult for other Bundesliga teams except Bayern to maintain their long-term competitiveness. Many people think that this is related to Bayern's "poaching". Frankfurt President bruch Hagen said: "With the combination of boateng and Hummels, Bayern will expand its advantage and Dortmund will lose Hummels in the second place-this is not a good decision for the Bundesliga."
Watzck once said that Bayern is destroying Dortmund.
Martin Samuel, a celebrity of the Daily Mail, also talked about this matter: "If Bayern always digs core players in the second best team in the Bundesliga, how can they be defeated?" But the problem is that Bayern will rule in the Bundesliga, but if it is in the Premier League, they can't. "When Wan Le joined Bayern, many people thought it was the last straw to end the Bundesliga suspense. However, Hummels chose to go to Bayern when Dortmund performed very strongly in the 20 15-20 16 season. This argument needs to be discussed again. Dortmund CEO Wozke also complained: "Bayern is destroying Dortmund. "According to the report in Sports Picture 20 14, Watzck decided to' break off diplomatic relations' with rummenigge at that time because rummenigge openly discussed the issue of Royce's breach of contract.
Business is business, and other giants also dig.
Leverkusen didn't sell vidal to Bayern at that time.
Although Bayern's "poaching" has caused a lot of criticism, many people say that this is a normal transfer transaction and there is no need to make a big move. Leverkusen Sports director Waller disagreed with Wozke's statement that "Bayern ruined the Bundesliga": "Bayern always wanted good players to enhance their strength, and they needed world-class stars, just like Real Madrid. They also have this economic strength, and business is business. Although they took Ballack and Ze-Roberto from us, which was in line with the rules, we succeeded in vidal and Bender and kept them. The situation in Dortmund is different. Gotze has a termination fee, and Levan is a free transfer. " Vidal wanted to move to Bayern, but Holczhauser, CEO of pharmaceutical factory, made it clear that Vidal would not be sold to Bayern. Finally, the Chilean star went to Juventus.
Some players moved abroad from the Bundesliga team.
It is normal for players to pursue more championship trophies and higher salaries. In the era of increasingly commercialized football, Bayern's success on and off the court also gives them more funds to attract players. Both the pharmaceutical factory and Dortmund executives have said that they cannot compete with Bayern in terms of player salaries. For players who play in the Bundesliga, it is a natural choice to stay in Germany, and if they want to pursue better treatment and win the championship, it is not difficult to understand that they choose Bayern. It is precisely because the salary is difficult to compete with the giants that it is not easy for other Bundesliga teams to keep their own players. Even if Bayern doesn't dig, other giants will do it. Players like Rosicky, Van der Vaart, Ozil, Khedira, MerTesak, Diego, Shaheen, Berbatov, De Braune, Kagawa Shinji, Zhe Ke, Huller, Terstegen, etc. , chose to join Real Madrid Barcelona or go to the Premier League.
Meng Xing, who reached the Champions League final in the 1970s, also found it difficult to keep the core lineup.
Klopp once said that Dortmund is not a club that can keep players: "This kind of thing always happens, and our best players often choose to leave at some point." What if Bayern doesn't dig people? /kloc-mö nchengladbach in the 1970s is an example. 1969- 1977 Eight seasons, Menxing won the Bundesliga championship five times, overwhelming Bayern three times, and also reached the Champions League final in 1976- 1977 season. During this period, Inner Mongolia did not sell any players to Bayern Munich, but Nozel, two main German internationals, Bonhoff and Stillick, and allan simonsen, who won the Golden Globe Award, all chose to go to La Liga. Menxing didn't want to sell simonson to Barcelona, but waited until the contract expired before going abroad. Some core members, such as Vogt and Heinks, chose to stay in the team. As Waller said, some efforts to keep players failed, and some succeeded.
As Dortmund star Riddle said, it is difficult for other teams in the Bundesliga to compare with Bayern. They always want the best players. These things do happen and may continue in the future, but they are hard to stop. Digging up competitors is definitely harmful to the desperate team, but it is also part of the football transfer.