Orochimaru used filth to reincarnate the fire shadows of past dynasties. Was the fourth generation stopped by the third generation, or could it not be summoned?

Because the first generation and the second generation didn't die of ghosts, the fourth generation put their souls in the body of a god of death to seal Kyubi no Youko. It is reasonable to say that orochimaru's ability at that time should have failed to summon the fourth generation. If it was determined that the fourth generation could be successfully summoned at that time, it is reasonable to say that the reincarnation of the filthy soil should not be prevented. In the late Ninja Wars, basically no one stopped the reincarnation of the filthy soil, so it was said that the summoning of the fourth generation failed at that time. Or was it successfully suppressed by the three generations of Huoying?

haha, this question is interesting. When orochimaru used dirty soil to reincarnate against the three generations of Huo Ying, was the fourth generation of Huo Ying unable to summon or was stopped by the three generations of Huo Ying? In fact, there are many changes in the settings of Naruto in the middle, early and late stages, and even the plot settings of comic version and animated version are different. If we look at the settings of Naruto in the later stage, it is said that the four generations of Naruto could not be summoned at that time. Let's explain it in detail.

Dirty metempsychosis can't summon a character whose soul is not in the pure land, so there is no third coffin in the comic version.

Everyone knows the conditions for the reincarnation of filthy soil. Only the dead whose souls exist in the pure land after death can be successfully reincarnated by filthy soil. The four generations of Huo Ying gave his soul to death because of the use of ghosts, so orochimaru could not reincarnate the four generations of Huo Ying's filth. In the related story of the comic version, orochimaru actually summoned only two coffins, and the third one did not appear at all.

Therefore, personally, I think orochimaru here should say that he wants to try whether he can summon four generations of Huoying, but he really can't. Originally, if the animated version had followed this setting, there wouldn't have been so many controversial things in the future, but it was added to the picture. It seems that the animation production team still didn't understand the conditions and restrictions for the use of the filthy soil. There is no third coffin in the comic version at all, that is, the soul of the four generations of Huo Ying is not in the pure land and can't be summoned at all according to the setting of metempsychosis.

There is indeed a third coffin in the pre-design of the animated version of Huoying, and there is a word on it, which makes many people mistakenly think that it is the fourth generation of Huoying. According to the design of the animated version, this stage should be stopped by the third generation of Huoying.

In the process of the animated version of orochimaru attacking Muye Village and the third generation of Huoying's one-on-one hit, orochimaru used the filthy soil to reincarnate the third coffin, with a word written on it. According to the content at that time, it should be that the animation production team got out the coffin of the fourth generation of Huoying.

Personally, I think the production team may want to show that the powerful strength of the three generations of Huoying can stop the process of reincarnation, but it is actually gilding the lily. Many people say that the "Four Represents" may be the fourth generation of wind shadow. After all, the wind shadow was also killed by orochimaru, but the four words on the third coffin in the story recalled by Dou in the back are gone. It should be that the later animation production team found the unreasonable place in front to make up for it in order to follow the setting of metempsychosis. Therefore, I personally think that in the early animated version of the story of orochimaru versus the three generations of Huo Ying, the third coffin should be Namikaze Minato. The reason why there is no filth in the end is because of the ability of three generations of Huo Ying to be two places at once in shuriken, not because the soul is not in the pure land.

The difference between the early animated version and the comic version lies in the addition of a third coffin, and the third generation of Huo Ying knows the identity of the reincarnated person. Therefore, according to the idea of the animation production team, orochimaru was able to reincarnate the four generations of Huo Ying at this stage, but it was stopped by the third generation of Huo Ying.

Finally, in the story of asking for the reincarnation of dirty soil with a clay elephant pocket, the four words on the third coffin in the early animation version are missing, in order to keep consistent with the comic version.

With the passage of time, many people began to question the setting of orochimaru's filth reincarnation in the early animated version. Is the third coffin falling to the ground a four-generation fire shadow? In order to dispel the doubts of Naruto fans and make up for the overkill caused by the animation production team, it is impossible for the fourth generation of Naruto to be reincarnated in the later stage of Naruto's plot. The evidence lies in that when Dou introduced the steps of the reincarnation of Dirty soil to Daitu, he mentioned that people whose souls are not in the pure land could not be summoned by using Dirty soil, and recalled the process that orochimaru used Dirty Soil to reincarnate against three generations. Here, it was explicitly mentioned that the fourth generation of Naruto could not be reincarnated.

But at this stage, the four characters on the early third coffin have disappeared. In order to fit the setting that the fourth generation of Huoying cannot be summoned, according to the setting of the later animated version of Huoying, it is not that the third generation of Huoying prevented the fourth generation of Huoying from being reincarnated by filth, but simply could not be greeted. Personally, I think orochimaru should try to summon the fourth generation of Fengying to deal with the third generation of Huoying.

The four words on the third coffin disappeared in the process of memory, in order to fit the setting that the soul is not in the pure land and cannot be reincarnated. Therefore, in the early settings of the animated version, the third coffin was actually given to Namikaze Minato. If the settings are not contradictory, there is no need to change the settings later. Therefore, according to the setting of the later animated version of Huo Ying, the third generation of Huo Ying did not prevent the fourth generation of Huo Ying from being reincarnated by filth, but could not be summoned.

Finally, to sum up, due to the long length of Huoying, there is a problem of inconsistent settings before and after. According to the settings in the later stages of Huoying cartoon and animation, the fourth generation of Huoying can't be reincarnated without the credit of the third generation of Huoying, but the soul of the fourth generation of Huoying is not in the pure land. However, according to the pre-set of Huoying Animation Edition, the fourth generation of Huoying was still made by orochimaru, because the attack call of shuriken of the third generation of Huoying failed. Please forgive me if the analysis is not in place. Please leave a message for discussion if you have other ideas.