Who is more powerful, Guan Yu or Zhang Fei in history?
Who is more powerful, Guan Yu or Zhang Fei in history?
Who is more powerful, Guan Yu or Zhang Fei in history? Because both Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are the top generals among the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei Taoyuan Three sworn brothers, the strongest and bravest man in the world, are often compared with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei. Let’s share who is more powerful between Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in history. Who is more powerful, Guan Yu or Zhang Fei in history? 1
I think Guan Yu is more powerful. According to "Three Kingdoms": (Zhang) Fei is majestic and mighty, inferior to Guan.
Zhang Fei was one of the best generals in the Three Kingdoms era. Speaking of bravery, he once led a small number of elite cavalry to scare off a large number of Cao's troops who were chasing Liu Bei; speaking of strategy, he once explained Yan Yan and cleared a large number of obstacles for Liu Bei to capture Xichuan; speaking of achievements, he once defeated Cao Wei's famous general Zhang He . Zhang Fei was an important minister of the Shu Han Dynasty. In the end, he became a general of chariots and cavalry, became a lieutenant of Sili school, and was granted the title of Marquis of Xixiang;
His two daughters became the queens of the Shu Han Dynasty; one of his grandsons became an official of Shangshu, and finally died in a battle with Zhuge Liang's son in Mianzhu. . Zhang Fei's management style tended to be strict, even cruel, and he was eventually killed by his subordinates because of this.
Historically, Guan Yu was indeed a man with a beautiful beard. Zhuge Liang wrote to Guan Yu that "he is still not as outstanding as his beard" precisely because of Guan Yu's beautiful beard. Guan Yu in history was indeed a man with a beautiful beard. Zhuge Liang wrote to Guan Yu that "it is not as good as the unparalleled beard" precisely because of Guan Yu's beautiful beard. In history, Guan Yu was called the enemy of ten thousand people by Cao Wei, and the famous general Wei Yu. He was called the General of Bear and Tiger by Soochow. Chen Shou called him the style of a national scholar, and he was a tiger minister in the world.
In history, it is true that the Seventh Army Flooded, scraping bones to cure poisons is also true (but not by Hua Tuo), it is true that he had friendship with Zhang Liao and Xu Huang, Cao Cao was so powerful because of him It is true that China wants to move its capital. Historically, Guan Yu was indeed captured by Cao Cao and forced to surrender. After beheading Yan Liang, he returned to Liu Bei. When discussing martial arts in later generations, Guan and Zhang were the first to be praised. At the end of the Jin Dynasty, there was a fierce general named Chen An who held a seven-foot sword in his left hand and a snake spear eight feet in his right hand. He was known as Zuoguan and Youzhang. In other words, it is not impossible for Guan Yu to hold a broadsword. Who is more powerful, Guan Yu or Zhang Fei in history 2
Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both placed on the same level in "Three Kingdoms" and popular novels of the past dynasties. Regardless of the romance, in the official history, Chen Shou commented on Zhang Fei: Yu's second best; "The Biography of Cheng Yu", "The Chronicles of Emperor Wu", "The Biography of Guo Jia", and "The Biography of Jia Xu" all mentioned that Yu was mentioned on different occasions and from different angles. , fly, the enemy of ten thousand people.
Later generations, especially after Luo Guanzhong, often used this as a basis to put the two on the same level intentionally or unintentionally. In addition, they both used to defend Xuande from insults, and they once sat in the same room and slept together. They sleep together, so few people suspect it. But the root of this matter actually lies in the credibility of "Three Kingdoms".
Who said that this book is the official history established by the emperor, and it is also the best among the Twenty-Four Histories. The whole text is less than 700 pages, and Chen Shou deleted it again and again, and what was left in the end was the essence. However, this is not the case. Lu Simian once analyzed this matter in detail in "History of Qin and Han":
If "Three Kingdoms" is a story passed down orally by people at that time, if "Three Kingdoms" is regarded as The reflection of the general knowledge of people at that time was not a big problem. However, it would be very inappropriate to regard it as a record of the people and events at that time. For example, "The Chronicles of Emperor Wu" records a passage from Cao Cao's childhood, saying how he had a battle of wits and courage with his uncle. This kind of thing can be viewed as a story at best, but if it is truly believed, it is quite ridiculous.
There is no need to spend time proving here. There is no historian who has heard or seen what Cao Cao said when he was a boy. Not only the historian, but also Cao Cao’s own memory is somewhat true or false. It doesn’t count. Another example is that in the "Biography of Xu Chu", it is said that he was so powerful that he once walked more than a hundred steps holding an ox's tail with his bare hands. Such records can only be regarded as stories and cannot be believed to be true.
Of course, Lu Simian did not completely deny all the contents in "Three Kingdoms", but only part of it. For example, historical dates, major events that occurred at that time, etc., even if there are problems with Chen Shou's records, it would be difficult to deceive the world and steal his reputation. At the same time, many historical books that were not contemporary at that time are often more reliable than contemporary books because there are no conflicts of interest.
For example, many records in "Zi Zhi Tong Jian" are more reliable than "Three Kingdoms". For example, "Three Kingdoms: Chronicles of Emperor Wen" says that Cao Pi wanted to annex Soochow, and when he reached the Yangtze River, he suddenly changed his mind and withdrew his troops. Comparing "Zizhi Tongjian Volume 81", we can find that this is obviously a matter of interest, defending Cao Pi. "Zi Zhi Tong Jian" said that Cao Pi underestimated the width of the Yangtze River and the strength of Stone City at that time. The river was more than 40 miles wide, and the river was fast, making it impossible to cross the river on a large scale.
"Sun Tzu's Art of War" states that a general must be wise, trustworthy, benevolent, courageous and strict. This can be used as a standard when comparing the level of generals. In "Three Kingdoms", Guan Yu and Zhang Fei basically belong to the same level in these five aspects. Wise man, during Guan Yu's Northern Expedition, he knew how to use the wavering forces around Cao Wei to oppose Cao Wei. The bandits Liang, Jia, and Lu Hun may have received Yu's seal from afar and supported him;
Zhang Fei was covering his head and knew Taking advantage of the terrain, he defeated Zhang He. The mountain road was narrow and Zhang He could not save each other from behind, so he flew to defeat him.
Believers, Guan Yu put righteousness first in his life. Of course, his righteousness was divided into objects. It didn't matter at all to the people he looked down upon.
Zhang Fei was like this. Changbanpo used his own power to seize the water and break the bridge. He did not let Liu Bei down. You two have never learned from Liu Bei. Chen Shou commented: Yu treats his soldiers well but is proud of the scholar-bureaucrats, Fei loves to respect gentlemen but does not care about villains. It can be said that they are both wearing colored glasses. Yong and Yan are their core competitiveness, let alone mentioning them.
However, the Eastern Jin Dynasty history book "Errors in the Three Kingdoms" records the strength and weakness of the two, which subverts history and cognition. "Discrimination of Errors in the Records of the Three Kingdoms" was first included in "Sikuquanshu". Qianlong evaluated this book and said that no one would accept it if it was credible or not in the official history. Only those who had confirmed it would adopt it.
For example, when correcting the "Wudi Chronicles", this book clearly stated that instead of exhausting efforts to think about the evidence, it is better to simply understand the deeds of Cao Cao in his childhood or youth. Not recorded to avoid misunderstanding by future generations. It can be said that this book adopts a completely calm critical attitude towards "Three Kingdoms", with almost no subjective color. After misunderstanding, it is easy to find that Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were not at the same level in history.
Except for following Liu Bei in his early years, and except for the fact that the two official positions were not far apart after Liu Bei became king and emperor, they are not at the same level in other aspects. In fact, the most obvious thing is that after Liu Bei entered Yizhou, he handed over Jingzhou to Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang instead of Zhang Fei.
Compared with Zhang Fei, his most outstanding achievement in his life was just his defeat of Zhang He. Moreover, Zhang He was not defeated in the first battle. According to "Discrimination of Errors in the Chronicle of the Three Kingdoms", He returned with dozens of his men. It is possible that this was just Zhang He leading a small force to explore the road. In fact, later generations often put Guan Yu and Zhang Fei on the same level. There is another reason why they believe that the two have equal strength.
However, there are two obvious misunderstandings in this understanding. First, comparing the strength of two people cannot only use the level of force as the criterion. This is obviously due to the deep influence of "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms". Secondly, in ancient wars, it was rare for generals to fight in single combat, and the role of individual bravery was very limited. Therefore, the famous scholar Lu Simian once said that Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, one is at the level of a prince and the other is at the level of a minion, they are not on the same level at all. Who is more powerful, Guan Yu or Zhang Fei in history 3
1. The top 100 military generals of the Three Kingdoms
The top 100 military generals of the Three Kingdoms are Lu Bu, Guan Yu, Zhao Yun, Dian Wei and Zhang Fei , Ma Chao, Xu Chu, Wen Chou, Yan Liang, Huang Zhong, Zhang Liao, Tai Shi Ci, Sun Ce, Gan Ning, Xiahou Dun, Pang De, Zhang Jia, Zhou Tai, Wei Yan, Xia Houyuan, Xu Huang, Wen Yang, Zhang Xiu, Jiang Wei, Deng Ai, Sun Jian, Hua Xiong, Guan Ping, Guan Xing, Zhang Bao, Ling Tong, Le Jin, Li Jue, Guo Si, Cao Zhang,
Yanggu, Shamoke, Gao Shun, Jiang Qin, Dong Xi, Cao Ren, Han Dang, Huang Gai, Cheng Pu, Chen Wu, Ji Ling, Li Dian, Xu Sheng, Ding Feng, Wang Shuang, Pan Zhang, Liao Hua, Zhu Rong, Ma Dai, Cao Hong, Meng Huo, Ling Cao, Lu Meng, Yan Yan, Ma Zhong, Guo Huai, Sun Huan, Zhu Huan, Wang Ping, Zu Mao, Yu Jin, Li Yan, Wu Anguo, Pan Feng, Wenpin, Xia Houba, Cao Xiu, Ma Teng,
< p>Liu Bei, Zhang Hu, Le Wei, Gongsun Zan, Han De, Man Chong, Cao Zhen, Cao Shuang, Hao Zhao, Ma Zhong, Zhang Ji, Fan Chou, Zhu Ran, Zhang Yan, Cai Mao, Zhang Yun, Wu Yi, Wu Ban, Dong Jue, Meng Da, Liu Feng, Mi Fang, Fu Shiren, Niu Jin, Fu Qian, Zhong Hui, Xu Rong, Ju Yi, He Qi, Su Fei, Ma Tie, Ma Wan, Guan Suo, Zhang Da, Fan Jiang, Lu Gong , Huang Zu, Zhang Ren, Deng Zhong, Lu Xun, Zhou Yu, Sun Quan, these people are all heroes in troubled times.
2. Who will win in the battle between Guan Yu and Zhang Fei?
Guan Yu is one of the top five military generals in history and he is very powerful. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei have much greater hope of winning in a battle with Guan Yu. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both outstanding masters of explosive power and endurance. The two have fought in the battlefield for many years, supporting Liu Bei wholeheartedly. Guan Yu's reputation for passing five passes and killing six generals was not in vain, but Zhang Fei's roar at Changbanpo scared Xia Houjie to death and also shocked everyone.
Both of them have long been famous, but in a real battle, Zhang Fei is no match for Guan Yu. Guan Yu's Qinglong Yanyue Sword weighs 82 kilograms. Guan Yu, who is angry, is almost unbeatable.